Suggestions
Explore the featured selections!
18 Cheese Pizza
Bosss BBQ Wings
12 Fulton St
12 Times Square 42nd St
About
NY Pie
Welcome to NY Pie, where the vibrant essence of New York meets the sunny disposition of Santa Rosa, California. Nestled at 65 Brookwood Ave suite 1 & 2, this Italian eatery specializes in delectable pizzas, refreshing salads, and savory wings, catering not just to your appetite but to your entire dining experience.
From the moment you step inside, the atmosphere welcomes you with its casual vibe and friendly staff. The moderate noise level creates a perfect backdrop for gatherings, whether it’s a lunch break, dinner with family, or a late-night snack. Outdoor seating is available for those who prefer al fresco dining, and accommodations like wheelchair accessibility and gender-neutral restrooms ensure that everyone feels comfortable.
NY Pie is not just known for its inviting place; it’s the food that keeps customers returning. The Half and Half Pizza is perfect for those indecisive moments, allowing you to savor two flavors in one large pie. The wings, whether crispy Plain, Salt Pepper, or drenched in Buffalo sauce, are a must-try, offering a finger-licking good experience at just $12.49 for a small 6-piece order. And let’s not forget the Garlic Knots, tossed in buttery goodness and adorned with Parmesan cheese, which are simply to die for! For those with a sweet tooth, the Sweet Knots provide a delightful end to your meal with their cinnamon and sugar twist.
What truly sets NY Pie apart is their commitment to quality ingredients and exceptional customer service. As our patrons have noted, the owner, Doug—who has roots in New York—brings an authentic touch to every pizza. Customers have voiced their satisfaction, with one remarking, “It’s not exactly NY pizza, but it’s pretty darn close!” The sauce is praised for its spot-on flavor, and the fresh herbs add another layer of depth to the dishes. More than just a meal, it’s an experience reminiscent of the bustling streets of New York, right here in California.
In addition to dine-in, NY Pie offers convenient delivery and takeout options, making it easy to enjoy their offerings anywhere. Plus, they accept various payment methods like Apple Pay and Android Pay, ensuring a smooth transaction process. And if you’re coming with a group, the restaurant is great for gatherings, and catering options are available for larger events.
Join the ranks of satisfied patrons like Jennifer B. and J. Steve F., who rave about the quality and taste that NY Pie consistently delivers. With their extensive beer selection to pair with your meal and free Wi-Fi for those needing a place to work, it’s clear why this spot has become a local favorite.
Whether you’re a true New Yorker seeking a taste of home or a Californian looking for delicious pizza, NY Pie promises an unforgettable dining experience!
For more information, or to place an order, give them a call at (707) 526-9743.
Book a table
Make A Reservation
“ Sooooo Good! Stopped here by recommendation from one of the wineries we stopped at with some east coast friends from out of town. It's not exactly NY pizza but it's pretty darn close! Closer than any other pizza place claiming they are NY pizza. Hands down the best I've had since moving out to California. The sauce is spot on! Talking with the owner Doug, they have been there 8 months. He is originally from NY and moved out west like so many of us many years before but I'm glad I got to chat with him. I got one white slice that I ate while sitting down and had one plain to go. I took a bite and it was delicious but next test was to taste it the next day which is why I chose a plain slice. It was still delicious and tasted like what I remembered! I'm so happy. I don't live that close but I plan to be back on my days off next month! Thank you NY Pie! They also serve salads, wings and knots. They serve beer (big selection) too. ”
“ Got delivery, was a bit late but it was Friday night so no big deal. Pizza was still fresh and delicious. First time trying NY pie,will be coming by for a slice frequently! Too good not to ”
“ I loveeee this place!!! They have a fabulous beer selection, and their pizza is soooo good. My kids always ask to come here on Fridays. This place can get busy(duh), but the service is still top notch! Lots of happy smiling faces , the manager even came by to make sure everything was ok! This is definitely our favorite local pizza spot, it should be yours too! ”
“ Well I finally got in here to try their pizza. I was impressed and pleased. This is pizzeria style pizza done really well. The quality of the ingredients is really good. They put fresh herbs on some of their pizza. I had a huge slice of the mushroom pizza. I actually saved half of it for the next meal. I was awesome impressed by the ranch dressing which had fresh herbs in it and tasted great and homemade. They're doing a good job here and I recommend it. ”
“ Never been here so decided to get some slices. Little did I know that the slices were bigger than my head which makes sense given the price. Nothing spectacular about the pizza, wasn't too greasy which was good, maybe could have used a bit more sauce but otherwise pretty good. Didn't get to go in but based on what it looked like from outside, seemed like a chill place to hang. I'd probably give it another go. Ear well or die trying -ant ”
“ We are so glad they opened their doors again. We love their menu. Service - 5/5 our server was attentive and friendly. She gave great suggestions so we didn't over eat or waste food. I believe one the owners was walking around talking to the customers. So friendly Food - 5/5 arugula small size was perfect to split among 2 adults. Our Flatbush pizza was tasty. I love the crust. It wasn't overly greasy. Add a little oregano and voila. We found out they have a rewards program so sign up. Look forward to our next visit. ”
“ My husband has been wanting to try this pizza for awhile now. It's a nice pizza place, all table/chair combos no booths and also has outdoor seating. Lots of beers on tap. We got the all meat large pizza. They put a good amount of toppings on but the crust is tough and chewy. I like to bite off pieces of my slice, I hate having to grip and tear it free. The sauce is very mild and definitely tasted like canned sauce. It is a good pizza but $47 (with $7 tip) for one pizza , only water to drink, it's should be better. Tastes very mediocre but the service was good. They have great ranch though. You can also get some good people watching done here with all the huge windows. ”
“ Place was great! I had literally never been here, not since or before the new ownership. We came here hoping for a slice & beer to watch a game and we ended up taking a leap of faith and ordered a full blown large pizza. This was meant to be, because the Longfellow Ave pizza was sooo good! Service was pretty quick considering rhat it was a busy football Sunday. I do wish theyd play the games a little louder on the speakers, but thats just my personal opinion. ”
